Shooting golf course roos ‘the last option’

04/Jan/2011

Comments: 36 readers have left a comment

Kangaroos on Joondalup Resort golf course. Kangaroos on Joondalup Resort golf course.

SHOOTING kangaroos on the Joondalup Resort golf course was the last option, according to course superintendent Ashley Watson.

As reported in last week’s Times, Department of Environment and Conservation officials were called in earlier this year to cull kangaroos that were damaging the course.

Mr Watson said kangaroos had caused few problems until late last year.

“They started homing in on the greens, I don’t know why, but they started digging holes in the greens,” he said.

Mr Watson said several alternatives were tried, such as putting different fertilisers and other materials on the greens to deter the animals, but nothing worked.

“One or two holes are not too bad but they were leaving 60 or 70 holes per night, we tried a few different products but nothing worked and the greens were becoming unplayable,” he said.

Originally, kangaroos were not suspected and it was only after course staff stayed overnight to monitor the greens that the cause of the damage was discovered.

Licensed DEC officers shot 13 kangaroos that were seen damaging the course in August and September, and Mr Watson said there had been almost no damage since then.

Wildlife activist Kim Walpole, who rehabilitates orphaned and injured kangaroos, was angered when she learned of the cull and said there were non-lethal methods available that were not considered by the DEC.

Ms Walpole called for a better kangaroo management policy, such as that in place for Victoria’s Anglesea region where kangaroos co-existed with the community.

She also called for the introduction of non-lethal methods of dealing with adult and baby kangaroos after learning that one female with furless pouched young were killed in the cull.

DEC officers must euthanase pouched young if the mother is shot and the prescribed method is “a single forceful blow to the base of the skull.”

A cull was last carried out at Joondalup Resort in 2007 but Mr Watson said local dogs were now more a threat to the animals than over-population.


Bookmark and Share

What everyone else is thinking

AnotherReasonToBeEmbarrassedToBeAus

09/02/2011

I read this article and just wanted to commend what has been written by the majority of those who have commented on the article. I love this country, but i despise the dominant discourse prevalent in 'mainstream' society. It is beyond disturbing that any individual can feel justified in ending a life simply because of something so trivial.
It is irrelevant that kangaroos are a unique and beautiful animal endemic to Australia, what is relevant is that it is socially acceptable to END A LIFE for no valid reason. It's the colonial mentality that 'this is our land' and just as it has always been, if anything gets in the way of what you want, simply eradicate it. I am a non-Indigenous Australian & deeply shamed.
I've been lucky enough to live abroad, and in many countries. I used to proudly say that I was Australian...not anymore.
I've been to this place quite a few times, as has my extended family, and we always spend quite an amount of money. We will never be going back

Joanne Copeland

11/01/2011

Its disgusting and a quick fix to kill kangaroos doing something they probably didn't even do. The ones losing reality are those killing innocent animals and feeling the need to attack someone like Kim who does something worthwhile. A lot of people do get involve with native animals thus the need to defend their lives. The attacking emails sound like guilty minds to me... shame they didn't put all that energy into finding a non-killing resolve to the situation.

Krae

10/01/2011

I just wanted to add a little bit extra to the end of my comment as it is missing some vital words...

I don't think my husband and I will return to the resort unless the way management of the golf course handles the controlling of the kangaroo population in a more humane and responsible manner.

bri

09/01/2011

Shouldn't DEC look after our wildlife?

Cougar

09/01/2011

I like to play golf as a past time and part of why I enjoy it is to see the wildlife, especially the kangaroos. I have driven past the Yanchep Golf Course many times and the number of roos that are out on the green at dusk is absolutely amazing. Granted alot of these roos come from the National Park, but the course doesn't punish them for trespassing. I would choose to drive an extra 15mins to go there or to Wanneroo if it meant I was supporting a course that actually cherished their residents.

Why do people find it acceptable to allow this sort of inhumanity to occur when it comes to roos? If this were happening to cats or dogs, people would be up in arms and would not stand for it. Many farmers, and I'm sure Local Pocal and Roo Realist, have dogs. They may be working dogs or family dogs. I don't think you would allow this to happen to your cherished mates. Why do you attack Kim Walpole for standing up for her passion.

Cruelty of animals on any level is disgraceful.

Krae

09/01/2011

My husband and I recently stayed at Joondalup Resort for 2 nights. Our room was overlooking the green and we didn't see any roos, let alone 200. We didn't see any damage apparently caused by them. We are in the process of building to be amongst these native animals and can't wait to sit and watch these amazing creatures in their natural habitat.

I don't understand how the management can justify culling 13 (plus the in pouch joey) of these animals when they so proudly advertise them as an attraction of the course. Unfortunately, as beautiful as the resort is, I don't think my husband and I will return to the resort unless the way management of the golf course handles the controlling of the kangaroo population.

kim walpole

08/01/2011

Cienwin that was so perfectly put. I am white, and so ashamed of the terrible state this country is in because of whiteman, and also the terrible abuses inflicted upon the awesome kangaroo, and the pouch young. It is cruelty beyond measure and I for one am proud to get 'emotional' when it comes to their welfare. Legalized animal cruelty has no room in a modern society, as we all like to see animals treated with respect and humanity, but for some reason, when it comes to kangaroos, it is literally 'open season'. A whole society falls short when it turns a blind eye to any animal cruelty and you know society has failed when words have to be changed to lessen what happens to kangaroos in the bush by those who work for the Kangaroo Industry, Words such as; slaughter becomes culls, shooting becomes harvesting, bludgeoning becomes euthansia...and so on. Hypocritical double-speak with no morality or humanity to a sentient being who has feelings, awareness and strong social bonds.

Antje Struthmann

08/01/2011

I would like to see the footage of Kangaroos digging please.
I am not convinced that they are responsible for the many holes.
There are more humane measures that can be taken to relocate the animals and they ought to be implemented.
On the other hand humans shouldn`t be so greedy and believe that every piece of dirt is theirs.
It is not. there is something called co -ohertion. Meaing living together.


Cienwen Hickey

08/01/2011

Emotion come to the fore where animals are concerned so to expect those who love our wildlife not to be emotional is unacceptable.
Australian wildlife belongs to the people of Australia, not any Governments.
Governments are given a mandate granted by the constituency to act as its representative.
In the case of culling permits this is not happening, the Governments,
State and Federal do not consult with the constituency as to the fate of their wildlife, this is dictatorial, not democratic.
White man came here, put up fences, built houses, moved in cattle and sheep and then expected the wildlife of this country to comply with their way of life.
It is unforgivable that the arrogance of a culture expects what has been here for thousands of years to conform to their way of life.
Native animals are being killed by the tens of thousands every year because of a problem created by white mans culture We created a problem, the solution is not, shoot first, ask questions later.

Chris

07/01/2011

I’ve never heard such a ridiculous excuse to kill native animals in my life.

Paul Falconer-West

06/01/2011

Local Pocal and Roo Realist are still hiding behind their pseudonyms. Are they one and the same? Or are they perpetrating a joint defensive stance over the killing of the 13 kangaroos and in-pouch joey. Despite the stated experience and concern for our environment and wildlife, your accptance of the killing of these kangaroos and joey cannot be justified in any way. Your personal attacks on Kim Walpole are unwarranted and cannot be justified either.

Maggie

06/01/2011

It's a very sad day when a bunch of people hitting a small ball around a set course for pleasure is more important than the lives of kangaroos that are native to the area. There is no justification for the brutal killing of the kangaroos and their young. I wonder how many golfers even think about the lives of any creature other than themselves. I am disgusted at this killing of the kangaroos and wish to applaud Kim Walpole for her stand on this issue and for valuing our unique wildlife.

Mari

06/01/2011

I'd like to know just exactly what experience with native animals "Local Pocal" has had compared to experienced wildlife carers (and comments like "latte drinkers" just show his ignorance) - I assume just hitting a little white ball around manicured grass, that some native animal has now had the cheek to "invade". It was originally their territory anyway, so if you don't want them invading what you now consider is "your" territory, then fence it off!

sylvia raye

06/01/2011

Man certainly is a strange animal. When a ball becomes more important than life, we are in trouble. Face the truth, we humans are barbaric, selfish, lack empathy and compassion and not as advanced as we think we are. We wonder why we live in such a cruel, hard world. Dont have to be a rocket scientist to work that one out. We should start culling and NOT the kangaroos!

elizabeth

06/01/2011

OMG!Local Pocal, who hides behind a psydonum, you really seem to have gotten yourself all 'upset'. I thought you were moving along...we aren't concerned about YOU, we are concerned about animal cruelty. Excuse me for saying 'how it really is'. bye bye...

elizabeth

06/01/2011

Actually we do 'get out' Dan that is why we know so much about the inhumane bludgeoning of pouch babies. And before we get into symantics of 'words' look them up in a dictionary. Humans cause damage as well, even more so when considering ALL developments ie; golf courses for example, which once had their own eco-systems, where nature lived in harmony with each other and then come along HUMANS. Please, your arguments are only supporting 'animal cruelty'. Remember: Kangaroos are kangaroos, golf courses are golf courses, no other Northern Suburb GC kill their resident roos.

V Smith

05/01/2011

We lived near the golf course for many years when it was owned by the then JDC who promised that it would always be a public owned course, we co -existed with the animals for years, and visitors thought how terrific it was to be living along side the roo's then the course went to overseas ownership, since then less roos, massive $'s to play a round, unspeakable yearly membership, and now the roo's being shot, all of this for the big end of town, we must not upset our overseas visitors they might not like an over supply of roo's.
If this course was still a public course how many roos would be killed for the convenience of the golfers?

Roo Realist

05/01/2011

I agree with Local Pocal. Far to much emotion & hand wringing by the antis. At the end of the day folks, what DEC has done is entirely legal. Culling & the kangaroo industry is carried out under strict scientific criteria, by licensed professionals (such as LP), who are very good at what they do. Despite the hysteria, every professional shooter I know cares deeply about the environment & our great Aussie bush, plus the fauna & flora that exists there.There are vastly more Red, Grey, & Wallaroo numbers than ever existed before white man came to this country & has been stated, this has caused some tragic scenes of starvation (yes, I too have seen much of this). Having said all that, I personally would have no trouble with someone such as Kim Walpole putting their hand up to move such as these animals from my local golf course. I take it you have already contacted DEC to do exactly this in future KW ? I for one would be happy to play at JRGC.

Dan

05/01/2011

Get a grip kangaroos do a hell of a lot of damage maybe some of you should get out a bit more

As for roos not digging holes did you come to that conclusion from your armchair?

Local Pocal

05/01/2011

What has my experience been with native animals?

Let me see....
Born and raised in the bush, lived on farms and stations in 3 states for years, currently spend 15-20 days a month not living in the city.
I have worked closely with fisheries in the past, in fact I have a shiny award for that.....
More recently I have worked closely with DEC to identify a small native marsupial I spotted one night, we are still working on that and it's very exciting as if it is what we think it is, then it appears to be about 500km out of it's known habitat, and there's a small but robust population of them.
When was the last time you "found" something like that on the cafe strip and went out of your way to assist with identifying it?

I commend Ms Walpole on her contributions, I disagree with some of the uninformed sentiments being bandied around is all, get over yourself mate.

Susie

05/01/2011

Yes, LP move along....the world of humanity has overtaken you... but ha ha, thanks for the laughs...harvesting with a gun! give me a break!

Paul Falconer-West

05/01/2011

Local Pocal is displaying a very emotive reaction to the truth revealed by Kim Walpole. He is also skating on thin ice with his "spreading lies" statement. Where is your evidence? Would it stand up in a court of law? Strange I did not see LP at the Pride of Australia Awards where Kim received recognition for her kangaroo caring. Neither did I hear LP interviewed on 6PR about his kangaroo caring! I suggest that LP provides real evidence of his damage claims. I have spoken to Yanchep Management who, unlike JRGC, do not slaughter their kangaroos. That is why you see so many roos as they also roam in the National Park. The Yanchep club delights in their presence, as do the players and the tourists. What has your experience been with native animals LP? What evidence do you have that can be verified?

Local Pocal

05/01/2011

To Kim Walpole:

I AM A LICENSED KANGAROO HARVESTER WITH D.E.C. So we can both throw around licenses, what of it? I, like all kangaroo harvesters (the new politically correct term for "roo shooters") have a very strong affinity with wildlife, we are not, contrary to popular belief blood thirsty murderers of tiny defenceless cute cuddly warm fuzzy baby's.
I see on a daily basis the effects of too many kangaroos/rabbits/cats/foxes in the great Australian bush, I see them starving after fires and droughts, I see them pushing each other into waterholes to drown and turn the water into a useless putrid stinking mess that no animal can benifit from.
I'm in no way saying that is the case on the golf course (I play golf, and I like to see them on the course) but what gets my goat is when people with NO IDEA start jumping up and down and rabble rousing over something just because it's got emotion attached to it.
It's a dozen roos, nothing to see here, move along......

kim walpole

05/01/2011

Oh dear, looks like the personal attacks are starting. Didn't take long.
Dictionary explantion of Bludgeoning is; strike with short thick club. Slaughter means: to kill, to kill for food. Sounds like those of us who care about animal welfare and suffering live more in reality than those who choose to 'turn a blind eye.' we get to see what other can not stomach.

kim walpole

05/01/2011

Just letting everyone know a few things as I have now been accused by 'Local Pocal' of being 'pompous'. Here is the reality, I AM A LICENCED WILDLIFE CARER WITH D.E.C. I live on a property, and like a lot of people who live in a rural environment, welcome the kangaroos as well as emus, echnidas, snakes, reptiles etc. We are blessed and privileged to live a true Aussie life surrounded by our unique nature, as well as FARM!!! I would gladly pick ticks if it was necessary and have done so over many years for my rehab joeys. I have also wiped their bottoms and given vet care if needed, all self-funded. I do 2hrly feeds for the tiny ones otherwise 4hrly. As for kangaroos and ticks. It is normal for them to be 'covered' in them this time of year, it is called 'nature'. And yes, I would help any wildlife, anywhere, anytime. As for Latte's - don't like them and would rather spend any spare money rehabing our much maligned kangaroos. Dreconian ways are changing.

Aaron

05/01/2011

Kim you have no idea really, nice emotive words there love. "Bludgeoned" you say.

Stick to the facts and you will do well.

There are millions of kangaroos in Australia, yet a small minority are shouting they are endangered, get out into the real world.

dhv

05/01/2011

The fact is that those most opposed to this event have lost touch with reality. Get a grip. Worry about issues of significance.

Local Pocal

05/01/2011

It's good to see the emotive arguement running rife by the sheeple yet again.
Grey kangaroos DO dig holes, and they DO destroy irrigation sprinklers, I have seen them doing it.
People running around spreading lies because it's the popularist option, let's all wring our hands in grief because a few kangaroos were shot.
Has anyone been to Yanchep golf course recently? I bet there are over 1000 kangaroos on that course, ( I have one photograph taken last week showing 173 on one fairway alone) and many of them are suffering tick infestations like you wouldn't believe, when are you do-gooders going to get out there and offer to de-tick them? Ms Walpole can volunteer to capture them for you.
That would be a great service and make you feel all warm and fuzzy inside, but the trouble is it would require you to get off your pompous butts and actually DO something.
Once you have had some experience of native animals come back and discuss the issue, until then go back to your latte's please.

Susie

05/01/2011

Mr Watson I have played regularly on JRGC and have never seen the results of 70 to 80 holes, or the patching up of holes and I have certainly never been aware of 200 kangaroos. Our long standing affiliation with Joondalup Golf Course is over. You have lost the support of my family, relations, friends and work colleages. It is not just the golfing dollars lost, but we all would eat and socialise which meant more dollars spent. We shall all definitely be golfing elsewhere where humans and wildlife coexist, and the club is not driven by money whilst exploiting the very animals they slaughtered.

janieb

04/01/2011

This comment from above sums it up well: "Killing an animal to preserve a golf course is outrageous".

They did this down at Preston Beach Golf Course near Waroona in 2010 too. Why is this allowed? We bulldoze, scrape and burn native animals' habitats and then cull the rest when they dare to impinge on a golf course. It makes me sick.

rainer repkpe

04/01/2011

Why is it that we cannot share nature with the animals that live there? How is it that DEC did not come up with a better answer? Destroy is easy, to think is pobably too much for these people. DEC has to comer up with a policy that forces joint existence of humans and animals (finally, we are animals too).
Rainer

Ribbon

04/01/2011

Why didn't they relocate the kangaroos?
Killing an animal to preserve a golf course is outrageous.

If you can comfortably kill a harmless animal I would hate to think what else you would consider doing to preserve the golf course.

Commonsence

04/01/2011

Of course all wild life must NOT be allowed to ruin the hallowed golf course. Its a sacred place to the select group of people who have nothing else to do but hit a little ball around untill they can get it into a hole. How dare they cull the kangeroos, it was their teritory first. Cruelty in the name of golf..you should all be ashamed.

Elizabeth

04/01/2011

The threat to kangaroos is not DOGS! but are the dreconian thought processers of lethal actions and a resistance to move beyond the 'old school' of wildlife management, as we humans confine and exploit said wildlife to attract money for business profits. But watchout kangaroos if you don't fit into our business model and we, as a business, have to pay for the privilege of exploiting you. Shame on you Joondalup Resort Golf Course, me and my family and friends will NOT BE BACK! and we will endeavour to spread the word of the cruelty to all and sundry as well as play golf at golf courses who are far more HUMANE!

Paul Falconer-West

04/01/2011

The big questions are - How were the alleged Western Grey culprits identified, in the dark, and them how did the DEC officers know which kangaroos to shoot on 27Aug10 and 10Sep10? Western Grey kangaroos DO NOT Dig holes - that has been scientifically proven. Red Kangaroos dig holes in sandy soil. There is no justification for this slaughter of our National Emblem.

Kim Walpole

04/01/2011

Just a few 'facts' about the recent cull at JRGC. Myth, Western Greys dig hole, Fact: they 'dust' themselves with sand, they mow grass. They don't dig and destroy grass roots as that would be counter productive for future food source. Rabbits and Golfers dig holes. If there has been digging, how did they find the 'culprits' in the dark. Fact: pouch babies are bludgeoned to death. Fear and pain would have been inflicted on that tiny life. Non-lethal methods are successful and please have in mind, JRGC have fenced in their resident roos, just like a wildlife park, so emerging pouch boys can be sterilized as is what we do when we can't release rehabed boys. There are no negative results of this method.

Share your thoughts in 60 seconds!

Members : login to comment


 

Wednesday 23 May 2012

  • Min 9°C
  • Max 21°C

Thursday

  • 8 - 22°C

Friday

  • 7 - 22°C

Most Popular Articles


community digital epaper link

Latest Competitions



Win a share in $20,000 of Coles groceries Go>:


driveway comp

Fuel up with Driveway Go>:



Win a double pass to Bel Ami  Go>:


Win a romantic getaway for two at Fremantle's finest!  Go>:


Win a double pass to the Good Food & Wine show Go>:


Win tickets to FRAGILE  Go>:



Featured Video Clips


2012 RAAF Pearce Air Show promo



Community Newspaper Group Photographer Jon Hewson goes for a spin in a P/C-9A Hawk to help promote the 2012 RAAF Pearce Air Show, held on May 19 and 20. Video, images and editing by Jon Hewson.



Circus performer Brenna Day



Circus performer Brenna Day talks about her career and upcoming performances in the Perth International Burlesque Festival. Video, images and editing by Matthew Poon.


See more videos 

email subscribe linkHBF junior sports hero
Deliver our newspapers linkCommunityPix banner linkSolahart