City refuses mosque proposal

13/Mar/2012

Comments: 8 readers have left a comment

A MOSQUE will not be built in Cockburn, after councillors unanimously refused to grant planning approval for a proposed bush lot on the corner or Lorimer and Russell roads in Munster.

More than 60 residents packed the council chambers for Thursday night’s council meeting, with chairs spilling out into the foyer and residents clamouring for an opportunity to speak during public question time.

The proposal by the Southern Metropolitan Muslim Association to build a Masjid, or multipurpose Islamic cultural centre on the 1.23 ha rural block, was quashed by City officers in the meeting agenda on the grounds of environmental impact, no potable water supply, traffic issues, noise, detraction from visual amenity and a land use inconsistent with a rural area.

The proposal also failed to gain the support of the Department of Health due to its non-compliance with the State’s sewerage policy.

Officers also took 424 public submissions into account and although 298 were in support of the proposal, 233 of those were from residents outside the Cockburn area, which the officers deemed as “important”.

Of the 168 submissions from Cockburn residents, 114 objected to the proposal with 23 objections and two supportive submissions from residents within 300 metres of the proposed site.

The officers’ report stated that despite the appearance of a genuine need for a mosque in the south-west metropolitan area, the overwhelming concerns of nearby residents, coupled with a proposal inconsistent with the earmarked block’s amenity, meant the City council’s support for it could not be granted.


Bookmark and Share

What everyone else is thinking

Jimbo

20/03/2012

Oh, it's for the Muslims. Of course, the decision just has to be racist. Any other religion and it would not even make the newspapers. I know, let's stereotype all Australians and say that a drive through liquor store will be built instead. Saying this makes me morally superior.

Al Pacino

19/03/2012

It would be good if the councillors provide alternative suggestions when declining an application like this. But that is unlikely if the reason for the rejection is based on prejudice. Australia is very racist.

gazza

18/03/2012

Seems they have chosen a site a fair distance away from any built up area to try and solve most of the perceived problems...Away from scheme water, away from established deep sewerage, and all they might upset are the cows...
So how does the council think t it might upset the "rural" scene...
They should have a gekko at the traffic in the 'small' country town of Bunbury!!!!
and in the bush, does not everyone depend on septic systems? As for water, how about an extended pipeline?.
Are these problems
UNSURMOUNTABLE????
And I am not a Muslim...but can see right through prejudice.

Arabian Knight.

14/03/2012


Hi, isn't this Australia?
There are too many mosques already.

Cranky Mouse

14/03/2012

Oh right, environment and traffic. Not racism at all. Cool.

Aubrey

13/03/2012

I would be curious as to how many people the proposed Masjid would have had the capacity to cater for over a six week period.


- then wonder what the second choice would be for all those people to do.?






secretsquirell

13/03/2012

rather have a drive thru' than a mosque

Honest John

13/03/2012

I`m quite sure that this site will be available now for a drive through liquor store and wil pass through council without notice.
I`m pleased i dont need to comply with Cockburn residents standards, and they are not my neighbours.

Share your thoughts in 60 seconds!

Members : login to comment


 

Tuesday 18 Jun 2013

  • Min 6°C
  • Max 18°C

Wednesday

  • 6 - 19°C

Thursday

  • 5 - 20°C

Featured Video Clips

Subiaco's Cinemas Project

Western Suburbs Weekly reporter Erienne Lette and City of Subiaco Mayor Heather Henderson talks about the new Cinemas Project.

Oliver Hill Gun Battery

Editor Denise Cahill talks with Harriet Wyatt about new conservation and restoration works being done to the Oliver Hill Battery.

Cat Haven Update

Western Suburbs Weekly editor Denise Cahill with this week's Cat Haven update.

Dog Refuge Update

Western Suburbs Weekly editor Denise Cahill with this week's Dog Refuge update.

email subscribe link
CommunityPix banner linkCarbonFootie