Bashed pensioner unhappy with attacker's sentence

04/Sep/2012

Comments: 18 readers have left a comment

Wally and his wife Janet with Canning MHR Don Randall. Wally and his wife Janet with Canning MHR Don Randall.

COMING to terms with the vicious assault that nearly killed him will take a Camillo senior years, but the man who caused the horrific injuries could be out of jail next year.

Robert Geoff Collard (21) was in the company of five children when he brutally assaulted 74-year-old Wally with a baseball bat.

The force of Collard’s frenzied and unprovoked attack shattered Wally’s right arm,  fractured a vertebrae, cracked three of his ribs and left the senior with cuts and bruises and an indentation to his head.

“He (Collard) was out to kill someone that night… and he found me,” Wally told Comment News.

Wally was out at 10.30pm on Sunday, October 30, last year trying to find the owner of a lost dog.

He does not go outside at night any more because the brutal crime has left him suffering not only physical pain, but also post-traumatic stress syndrome.

“My doctor now has me on anti-depressants. I’ll need to be on them for about two years,” Wally said.

“I don’t get the pension and I have a lot of medical bills to pay. This is different from Collard who is now getting free medical, dental, food and accommodation. I’m the victim, but I’m the one with the sentence … the physical pain, post traumatic stress and medical bills.”

Canning MHR Don Randall is concerned Wally did not receive the support he deserves and is calling for Collard to receive a tougher sentence.

Wally said Collard should have received a tougher penalty and he would have preferred the man was caned before being put in a cell.

His wife Janet said if Collard was let free, which could happen in 15 months time taking into account time served, he would not have had time to rehabilitate and could re-offend.

She said the offence had robbed her of the husband she once had.

“All of a sudden I became an alien to him because of his post-traumatic stress,” she said.

Wally said the fact that Collard bragged about the assault on Facebook upset him.

MHR for Canning Don Randall has written to the Director of Public Prosecutions to appeal against the three-year sentence given to Collard, who was on a conditional suspended imprisonment order when he committed the offence.

“To say this sentence is inadequate is a complete understatement and simply does not reflect the expectations of the community,” Mr Randall said.

Janet and Wally thanked Armadale detectives for putting Collard behind bars.
 
“Still, it mustn’t be easy for the police… knowing that they did all that work and Collard only got three years,” Janet said.

“I’m also grateful for the courageous lady who came to help me when she heard me screaming for help,” Wally said.

“The security light of her home came on and that’s when Collard fled. Another five minutes and he would have killed me.”



Bookmark and Share

What everyone else is thinking

janetmccall

19/03/2013

Robert should have got five year everyone that bashs old man or women should jail as they can noy defend then self

janetmccall

19/03/2013

Robert should have got five year everyone that bashs old man or women should jail as they can noy defend then self

Sheryl

08/09/2012

I feel for you Wally, isn't it about time we change the system and criminals start paying for their crime, coughing up the expense for Lawers, Medical, Counselling, ect.. for the damage they do to others, come on all Government Heads, hit the perpetrators where it hurts them, their pockets. Wally needs to be taken care of emotional, physcially by the State Government and his attacker pay the costs & do more time like 5 years in jail, no parole.

Collard

07/09/2012

I'm up for a good ol' baseball bat type punishment if anyone wants to join me. Its obvious our offspring have no respect for tribal law anymore so the only way to deal with them is to dish out as good as they give. What a disgrace our race has become. Colin Collard.

David

07/09/2012

I gave a young man a warning some years ago when he threatened me with violence. Knowing I couldn't beat him I said to him, if you do this you had better have eyes in the back of your head because one day you will turn a corner straight into a piece of 4 by 3, and I will be wielding it. He said to me "Your joking!" and I replied, "hit me and find out". He left me alone. He was also my stepson and a kinghitter.

Fox

07/09/2012

Roobub you clearly don't understand how sentencing in this State operates. This was not a lenient sentence when compared to sentencing on similar matters. It's silly to suggest that the sentence would be different if it had been the Judge's dad! The offender was dealt with by an unbiased judge, who carried out his sentencing task according to the laws of this State.

Roobub

06/09/2012

Sorry Fox - I disagree with your "criticizing the Judiciary or Criminal Justice system". The judge certainly got it wrong, and I say again - if this had to be his/her dad I doubt the "lenient" sentence would have been passed.

Rae

05/09/2012

I too wish you well Wally. Please know that there are many good people in this world who are thinking of you. Your attackers acted like a pack of wild dogs, without conscience or mercy. I agree that there needs to be harsher sentencing. It would be great to see prisoners performing community work and more money being directed from the criminals own pocket towards the victims recovery. Perhaps it would help for strong, recovered victims to meet prisoners on a frequent basis to personally tell them about the impact of their actions. Wally, I wish you peace and a rapid recovery. All the best.

Sasha

05/09/2012

This is disgusting, hope you recover well Wally.
Doing such a callous act is bad enough but doing it in front of children, what hope do they have in life with this as an example!

George

05/09/2012

I wish you all the best Wally.!!! I hope you recover fully.!!! There has to be a deterrent, giving 3 years for this crime is NOT a deterrent its a joke.!! Giving a longer sentence might not help Wally but hopefully it will prevent another victim from being assaulted soon. Don't forget this is not the first time this thug has assaulted someone and I predict it wont be the last. The Judges need to take a long hard look at themselves, what if it was their father or grandfather.???

Wendy Dyet

04/09/2012

I live just around the corner from this gentleman and his wife even though I dont know them personally I totally understand their frustration and their fears. This area has become so bad over the last couple of years and many of us live in fear of attacks both physically and on property. It was not long ago we had terrible attacks on our property as well as my own life threatened by a certain group of locals. We would be relaxing at night in front of our tv and bottles would come flying through our windows, we had cars vandalized , we lived constantly on the edge because these people Knew that the judicial system is on their side. Its time we as ratepayers and voters had the protection and the support of the system instead of us being the ones made to pay..We had to cancel our Christmas due to these attacks and the money WE had to spend on repairs, while the criminals continue on doing as they wish with no consequence.
Wont be long and vigilante groups will take no more.

Karen

04/09/2012

DITTO...Roobub..totally agree. These type of people are cowards, old people, women and children are the bullies favourite punching bags. Do gooders go home. Give these creeps the proper sentences they deserve.

jonesy

04/09/2012

The Judges need to reflect the seriousness of the crime instead of worrying about the future of the criminal.This mans life has changed for ever and the criminal should be punished properly by the judge.

Fox

04/09/2012

Three years is not a lenient sentence in comparison to sentencing for similar matters That judge is certainly not renowned for handing out light sentences. I feel very bad for the elderly man who was so viciously assaulted. However, criticizing the Judiciary or Crimnal Justice system is not going to help him.

Don Randall should be a bit more clued up on sentencing and a little less inclined to grandstanding by publicly proclaiming he's writing to the DPP. Really Don, your posturing does not impress!

Don Randall

04/09/2012

Sadly, Wally's case is not the only one that has come to my attention in recent months as we experience spiralling crime in the Canning electorate, particularly around the Armadale area. I will continue to work hard to insist on additional police resources in the area; however I must stress that all such endeavours are somewhat futile unless convicted offenders are appropriately punished. As we all know, criminals will always feel emboldened to behave as they like (with little or no regard for others) unless there is a deterrent in place. In recent days I have received an overwhelming response from local residents who have contacted the DPP to voice their outrage at the inadequate sentence handed down to Wally’s attacker. I will continue to stand up for such injustices as it is essential that innocent victims of crime are not further victimised by the imposition of completely insufficient sentences for brutal criminal acts. Don Randall.

gary

04/09/2012

WA justice system strikes again. Bring in SINGAPORE justice for all.

Patricia Halligan

04/09/2012

The passions are a natural component of the human psyche.Our Lord called a man's heart the source from which the passions spring so what was in the heart of the man who would mount such a vicious attack on another human being such as that endured by Wally?The free will is exercised in all our actions too and this man unprovoked into anger and hatred chose to pick up a baseball bat and hurt a weak old man and boast about it afterwards.Clearly this bully needs to learn the effect of his cowardly action on his victim by suffering pain himself.Before it was scrapped in Britain after the second world war British prison records show that few reoffended after corporal punishment. Violence is worse now so perhaps the time has come to reintroduce the birch for repeat offenders of violence.The do gooders in society will oppose it of course for its appeal to the cruel strain in all of us and the fact that some hardened criminals treat it as a badge of honour.




Roobub

04/09/2012

These type of "animals" should be trialed by jury and sentenced by jury !!! What a pathetic sentence JUDGE!!!! Don't tell me about human rights for prisoners - they violated that right when they committed the crime. Lets put the pensioners in prison (with open gates) so they have free EVERYTHING including FOXTEL and put the prisoners in the pensioners position - behind bars of course. Wally - I wish you all the best in your recovery - and shame on the justice system!!!!

Share your thoughts in 60 seconds!

Members : login to comment


 

Sunday 19 May 2013

  • Min 10°C
  • Max 21°C

Monday

  • 10 - 19°C

Tuesday

  • 9 - 21°C

Featured Video Clips

Subiaco's Cinemas Project

Western Suburbs Weekly reporter Erienne Lette and City of Subiaco Mayor Heather Henderson talks about the new Cinemas Project.

Oliver Hill Gun Battery

Editor Denise Cahill talks with Harriet Wyatt about new conservation and restoration works being done to the Oliver Hill Battery.

Cat Haven Update

Western Suburbs Weekly journalist Sarah Motherwell with this week's Cat Haven update.

Dog Refuge Update

Western Suburbs Weekly journalist Erienne Lette with this week's Dog Refuge update.

email subscribe link
CommunityPix banner linkCarbonFootie